Felicity also would have played with a Jacob's Ladder and a wooden hoop, ball and stick,and other wooden toys. You can Buy
children's sized Colonial Games in Williamsburg. BTW if you go to the Colonial Williasmburg Foundation Website and click on clothing-you can see pictures of a real fashion doll! I think the new doll for Felicity is more authentic.

Kirsten would have played physical games like hopscotch, tag, blind man's bluff

They all would have played jacks.

Here is another link to Early American themed toys

I bet if you go to the websites for the museums which have American Girl programs you can find out more about what games they would have played.